Back to the front page
American History

Oppenheimer: What We Realized The Movie Leaves Out

Oppenheimer winning award, shaking hands with President
Oppenheimer wins the prestigious Fermi award in 1963. Public domain.

Military Targets Weren’t Enough

Oppenheimer and dignitaries standing over remains of Trinity test site
Oppenheimer (in light colored hat) at the site of the Trinity test, September 1945. Public domain.

Nolan’s movie goes further into the committee’s conflict. The idea of a demonstration blast, one that would show Japan what the weapon could do was quickly shot down. Oppenheimer knew Japan would not surrender based on a demonstration, and a necessary US invasion of Japan would result in mass casualties. If the bomb failed during the demonstration, it would be humiliating.

The Interim Committee, tasked with studying nuclear weapon issues discussed warning target cities in time to evacuate civilians. The Interim Committee dismissed this idea. If Japanese forces knew of the bomb, either by demonstration or warning, they were capable of intercepting or sabotaging the bomb enroute. Ultimately, the decision to drop the bomb and on Japan was to force was to stop a war and halt the loss of more lives, at the cost of the lives of Japanese civilians, around 200,000 by the end of 1945.

Written by

Keep reading

Advertisement