Debunking Myths and Shedding Light on Viking Legend, Ragnar Lothbrok
Debunking Myths and Shedding Light on Viking Legend, Ragnar Lothbrok

Debunking Myths and Shedding Light on Viking Legend, Ragnar Lothbrok

Natasha sheldon - August 9, 2018

Debunking Myths and Shedding Light on Viking Legend, Ragnar Lothbrok
A Viking army in battle. Google Images. Public Domain.

Fact and Fiction

What is undoubtedly true is, soon after Ragnar supposedly died in the snake pit, the first serious waves of Viking invasions swept across Saxon England. In 865 AD, the Anglo Saxon chronicle describes how the Great Heathen army swept across the north of England. The leaders of the army, which was composed of warriors from Denmark, Sweden, and Norway, led their men to secure Northumbria for the Norsemen. Then in 867 AD, they moved onto York. The Vikings killed King Aella and King Osbertht.

This invasion sounds like the vengeance that Ragnar Lothbrok foretold; a vast army sent out to avenge the death of their greatest leader, killing the man responsible for Ragnar’s death and conquering new lands for the Vikings in the process. However, while the surface facts fit the legend, actual history does not support the idea of the Great Viking invasion as anything to do with Ragnor Lothbrok. The Anglo Saxon Chronicle that records the events of 865AD and beyond does not mention his name. However, what the Chronicle does mention is the names of some of the leaders of the Great Heathen Army. Two of them are particularly significant: Ubbe and Ivar.

We know that Ubbe and Ivar, like Bjorn Ironside, were real historical figures- not just from the Anglo Saxon Chronicle but from other sources. Their names come up time and again as leaders of Viking forces that tormented France, Ireland, and England in the second half of the ninth century. Ivar became the ruler of a Viking kingdom that stretched from Dublin to York. He died in battle in 873. Ubbe meanwhile seems to have outlived him. He died in Devon in 878. Bjorn Ironside is known to have raided along the River Seine between 857- 859 and is credited as a great explorer. Yet there is no historical evidence to suggest that any of these men were the son’s of Ragnar Lothbrok, let alone brothers.

Debunking Myths and Shedding Light on Viking Legend, Ragnar Lothbrok
Lothbrok, king of Danes, and his sons, Hinguar and Hubba, worshiping idols. Wikimedia Commons. Public Domain

In fact, the connection between Ragnar and his so-called ‘sons’ seems to postdate the ninth century by at least a century. In 1070 a Norman historian called William of Jumieges named a Danish King called Lothbrok as Bjorn’s father. Not long afterwards, the chronicler Adam of Bremen identified Ivar as a man called Ragnar’s son. Finally, in the twelfth century, an Icelandic scholar Ari Porgilsson climbed on the bandwagon. It was he who linked the names “Ragnar” and “Lothbrok” to create one person, so forming the basis for legends of Ragnar Lothbrok. Such a character could not have been the father of Ivar, Ubbe or Bjorn. However, there is the possibility that, like his name, Ragnar Lothbrok could be a composite figure based on actual people.

Debunking Myths and Shedding Light on Viking Legend, Ragnar Lothbrok
Viking Siege of Paris 845AD. Google Images. Public Domain

The Real Ragnar Lothbrok

Aside from the mysterious King Lothbrok who may or may not have been the father of Bjorn Ironside, there are a couple of real historical characters who could have formed the basis of Ragnar Lothbrok. The first is a Danish Viking called Reginheri or Ragnall. Like Ivar, Ubbe and Bjorn, Reginheri was active during the ninth century. A subordinate chieftain of King Horik, in March 845AD, he led 120 ships carrying 5000 warriors up the River Siene to besiege the city of Paris- just like the legendary Ragnar Lothbrok.

Despite having sacked the city of Rouen on their way to Paris, the Vikings were fighting fit. The Annals of Xanten describe the raid as vicious and uncompromising. For two days the Vikings held Paris under siege before the city capitulated. The Vikings had captured 111 men from the city garrison. Instead of keeping them as hostages, Reginheri had them sacrificed to the god Odin as a gesture of thanks for the victory.

However, this bloody act seemed to work to the Viking’s advantage. The Frankish King Karl der Kahle decided he wanted to be rid of these unwelcome and decidedly violent guests without further bloodshed. So he paid Reginheri 7000 pounds of silver and gold to go away. Reginheri was happy to oblige. He led his men back up the Siene, pillaging a few villages along the coast as they set off home. However, once he returned home to Denmark, Reginheri did not enjoy his victory for long. For the Vikings had brought something else back from Paris: a violent form of dysentery. It was from this, rather than a pit of snakes that finished off this particular Ragnar prototype.

Debunking Myths and Shedding Light on Viking Legend, Ragnar Lothbrok
Viking Raiders. Google Images

The second inspiration for the legendary Lothbrok is somewhat later. Rognvald or Ragnall ua Imair. Ragnall died in 921AD but was one of the earliest Norse rulers of Northumbria and the Isle of Man after the Great Heathen Army landed in England. Ragnall was one of a group of Vikings had who settled in Ireland sometime during the late ninth, early tenth century. While his kinsman, Sitric became King of Dublin, Ragnall settled himself on the Isle of Mann before moving in on the north of England. Here, Ragnall was more successful than Ragnar. For Ragnall fought Constantin mac Aeda, King of Scotland. While he did not beat the Scottish King, he weaken his hold on the north of England just enough for Ragnall to seize York in 918 and make himself King.

Neither of these figures make a complete Ragnar Lothbrok. Indeed, there are probably other, shadowy Vikings lost in history who never the less influenced the formation of the legend of Ragnar Lothbrok. For ultimately, that is what Ragnar is, a composite figure who acts as an encapsulation of all that the Vikings admired about themselves. In that sense, composite legend or not, Ragnar Lothbrok, is the ultimate Viking hero.

 

Where Do We Get this Stuff? Here are our Sources:

Ragnar Lothbrok, Encyclopedia Britannica, December 28, 2017

The Immortal Viking, Eleanor Parker, BBC History Magazine, July 2018

Ragnar Lothbrok/Lodbrok (Vikings), The Real Story: His Life, Death, Wives and Children, Mythologian.net

The Legend of Ragnar Lothbrok: Viking King and Warrior, Christopher Van Dyke, 2016

The Viking Sieges of Paris, Yulia Dzhak, War History Online, May 13, 2016

Ragnall ua Ímair, Wikipedia

Advertisement