5 Incredible Confessions in True Crime History
5 Incredible Confessions in True Crime History

5 Incredible Confessions in True Crime History

Lindsay Stidham - March 20, 2017

5 Incredible Confessions in True Crime History
James Brewer. Crime Magazine

2. James Brewer

In the 1970s James Brewer shot and killed his neighbor Jimmy Carroll when he thought he was trying to seduce his wife. When Brewer was granted bail, he fled town with his wife and they started a new life together under new names.

After Brewer had a stroke he decided he wanted to come clean about what he had done. His wife brought police to what they thought was his death bed and he told them what he had done. The only problem? Brewer didn’t die. When he was released from the hospital, he surrendered himself to police.

Friends of the family who knew Brewer and his wife from church said they were incredibly devoted to their faith. One even stated, “they’ve been in their own prison for thirty years. I think they’ve done their time.”

Brewer obviously thought otherwise since he made the confession at what he thought was the end of his life. He wife acted as his “translator” since the stroke affected his speech. Definitely file this one under strange confession.

5 Incredible Confessions in True Crime History
Robert Durst. Los Angeles Times

3. Robert Durst

It’s hard to do a feature on confessions without getting into the most famous one of the last three years. Durst was arrested in the spring of 2015 on a first degree murder warrant for the murder of Susan Berman.

Against advice of those close to him, Durst cooperated with HBO filmmakers of the documentary “The Jinx: The Life and Deaths of Robert Durst.” The documentary specifically examined the disappearance of Durst’s first wife, and the murder of Berman.

In a final interview with the filmmakers, Durst walked into a bathroom and confessed into a live microphone: “There it is. You’re caught! What the hell did I do? Killed them all, of course.”

In November 2016, Durst pleaded not guilty to the murder of Susan Berman. Durst entered the plea wearing a neck brace and sitting in a wheelchair. He is expected to have an official hearing this month in Los Angeles. It will be interesting to see the final verdict.

5 Incredible Confessions in True Crime History
Ted Bundy. The New Yorker

4. Ted Bundy

Ted Bundy keeps with the criminal tradition of making a confession right before death. Days before his execution, Bundy sat down for an interview with Detective Robert D. Keppel. The serial killer went into detail about he killed and dismembered victim Georgeann Hawkins.

While on death row, Bundy spoke a lot to Keppel to help him understand the mind of a serial killer. But before he spoke so openly with Keppel he made one last plea to try to maintain innocence: “I’ll tell you, as long as they attempt to keep their heads in the sand about me, there’s gonna be people turning up in canyons and there are gonna be people being shot in Salt Lake City. Because the police there aren’t willing to accept what I think they know and they know that I didn’t do these things.”

Before his final arrest, Bundy had managed to escape from prison and kill again. His good looks and manipulation even pulled the wool over the eyes of the police in that escape.

In 1989 Bundy was finally executed. He didn’t pull any punches before the very end, telling Keppel: “I think I stand as much chance of dying in front of a firing squad or in a gas chamber as you do being killed on a plane flight home. Let’s hope you don’t.”

5 Incredible Confessions in True Crime History
William Desmond Taylor. The Line Up

5. Silent But Deadly

In the 1920s, the death of director William Desmond Taylor was big news. A police officer showed up at his Hollywood bungalow to find him dead on the floor with a bullet in his back.

Actresses’ careers also died with Taylor’s murder. Mary Miles Minter was a budding teen star when Desmond started casting her in his silent films. After his murder her nightgown was found in his bedroom, as was a love letter.

Nonetheless, the case went unsolved for years. Many years later Minter wrote an autobiography and admitted that she and her mother were at the bungalow the night of the murder. Minter’s mother had previously threatened the life of another director that made a pass at her daughter.

Legend has it that when Minter’s mother suffered a heart attack, she attempted to a summon a priest so she could confess to killing Taylor. With no priest nearby to confess, she told all to a nearby neighbor and then died. Directors: be careful who cast…or don’t cast.