16. A Budding Criminal Career

McElroy got started small on his criminal path with petty thefts, graduated to livestock rustling, and soon escalated into violent assaults and vicious mayhem. He was helped by an intimidating appearance: the adult McElroy stood at over six feet, weighed in at 270 pounds, had bushy eyebrows and bushier sideburns, and heavily lidded, crazy-looking, cold steel-blue eyes that sent shivers down spines. For years, he harassed, threatened, and stalked the locals. Nobody saw him work, but he always seemed to have pockets full of cash, which he liked to show off. On one occasion, he reportedly covered the local bar’s pool table with $100 bills.



