Sources Claim Gandhi Used to Frequently Sleep Naked In a Bed With Young Girls... Including His Grandniece
Sources Claim Gandhi Used to Frequently Sleep Naked In a Bed With Young Girls… Including His Grandniece

Sources Claim Gandhi Used to Frequently Sleep Naked In a Bed With Young Girls… Including His Grandniece

Wyatt Redd - January 20, 2018

 

Sources Claim Gandhi Used to Frequently Sleep Naked In a Bed With Young Girls… Including His Grandniece
One of the ashrams Gandhi started/ Wikimedia Commons.

After taking his vows of poverty and chastity, Gandhi began setting up ashrams (essentially Hindu monasteries) to teach his ideas to others. But they were also intended to be places where Gandhi could experiment with the best way to stay chaste. These ashrams took in young boys and girls and began training them to live their lives without sex. Children and adults of both genders were expected to live, sleep, and even bathe together. But any sort of sexual talk or behavior was punished. And of course, Gandhi also subjected himself to these experiments in chastity.

Gandhi frequently slept and bathed with his young female followers. When others criticized this practice as being unseemly, Gandhi argued that it was a way for him to increase his spiritual power. And as Gandhi said of his practice of bathing with Sushila Nayar, the younger sister of his secretary, “While she is bathing I keep my eyes tightly shut. I do not know … whether she bathes naked or with her underwear on.” Obviously, it wasn’t an explanation that satisfied his critics. But the opportunity to bathe or sleep with Gandhi was seen as a great honor among his followers.

It was a sign that “Father,” as they called him, had taken a special interest in their spiritual development. But Gandhi seems to have taken a special interest in his female followers based on how young and attractive they were. When Sushila grew older, she found herself being replaced in Gandhi’s bed by his 18-year-old grandniece, Manu. According to Gandhi’s writings, these unorthodox experiments sometimes went further than just sleeping. Gandhi sometimes asked the women he slept with to perform strip-teases or make sexually explicit conversations. As Gandhi explained it, this was the ultimate test of his vow of chastity.

As to whether or not Gandhi might have ever given in to his urges, it’s hard to say. Some of Manu’s diaries describing her nights with Gandhi record some episodes that seem to be less than completely chaste. For instance, one entry describes how “when Bapu [Gandhi], Sushila, and I were sleeping on the same cot, he embraced me and patted me.” And some of Gandhi’s own writings include references to “accidents” that happened when he was sleeping with one of his followers. If the goal of the experiment was to stay chaste, then an “accident” might logically mean giving in to temptation.

Sources Claim Gandhi Used to Frequently Sleep Naked In a Bed With Young Girls… Including His Grandniece
Gandhi with Manu(left) and Abha(right), wife of his grandnephew/ Youtube.

It’s also worth mentioning that Gandhi probably slept naked through most of these experiments and expected the girls he was sleeping with to do the same. As Gandhi told Manu when she first came to his bed, “[we] must put our purity to the ultimate test, so that we know that we are offering the purest of sacrifices, and we should now both start sleeping naked.” Gandhi somehow connected the idea of spiritual purity with a young girl sleeping naked with her granduncle. Today, most people are fairly skeptical of this idea. And even at the time, people accused Gandhi of using spirituality to justify exploiting his followers sexually.

Sources Claim Gandhi Used to Frequently Sleep Naked In a Bed With Young Girls… Including His Grandniece
Mohandas and Indira Gandhi/ Wikimedia Commons

In 1947, Gandhi received a letter from a young man who had decided to leave his ashram. “I object to your practice of sleeping in the same bed with members of the opposite sex,” the man wrote. “Apart from the question of any effect on you, what about the effect on the girls?” It was a good question, and the letter also talks about the effects it did seem to have on the girls. “[The] Punjabi girl who lived opposite my room… She used to weep unrestrainedly. And then there’s Sushila-ben… how many are the days when she has not wept?”

From a modern point of view, it seems less like Gandhi was conducting spiritual experiments and more like he was exploiting young women who looked up to him to satisfy his sexual desires. Sushila Nayar, who was one of the earliest followers to share Gandhi’s bed, reported that this was probably the case. As she said following Gandhi’s death it was only, “Later on, when people started asking questions about the physical contact with women…the idea of experiments was developed… in the early days, there was no question of calling it an experiment.”

There’s little question that Gandhi kept up these “experiments” in the face of objections from many people around him. But even when people told him how much he was hurting his image as a leader of India, and hurting the women around him, he couldn’t seem to stop. In fact, the objections seem to have had the opposite effect on him. In a way, that makes sense. He was telling the world that these were spiritual experiments. If he stopped, he was admitting that his motivation was less pure. As Gandhi said, “If I don’t let Manu sleep with me, though I regard it as essential that she should, wouldn’t that be a sign of weakness in me?”

Even at the time, if they had been public information, they would have seriously damaged his image as “Father of the Nation.” Gandhi and the people around him seem to have understood that. That explains why, following Gandhi’s death in 1948, some of Gandhi’s family members made a serious effort to keep the experiments out of the public eye. Manu reported that Gandhi’s son Devdas approached her after Gandhi’s death and told her she should keep the diary she kept of the time she spent with Gandhi to herself.

Sources Claim Gandhi Used to Frequently Sleep Naked In a Bed With Young Girls… Including His Grandniece
Gandhi’s funeral procession/ Wikimedia Commons.

The effort to cover up Gandhi’s activity makes it clear that even those closest to him understood that what he was doing was fundamentally wrong. Or at least, they show that they understood that most people would have felt that way. But the cover-up was certainly effective. Even today, few people are aware of Gandhi’s strange experiments or the toll it took on the women around him. But the evidence we have available now paints a more complicated picture of Gandhi than simply a living saint. And it makes it clear that Gandhi’s public vow of chastity always had a secret, darker side.

 

Where did we find this stuff? Here are our sources:

The Independent: An odd kind of piety: The truth about Gandhi’s sex life

The Madras Courier: Gandhi: A Sexually Repressed Pervert?

BBC News – Gandhi Wanted Women To ‘Resist’ Sex for Pleasure

Times Of India – The Mahatma in The Bedroom

Open The Magazine – ‘On His Sexual Experiments, Gandhi Refused to Be Swayed by Disapproving Associates’

She the People – Experiments with Celibacy, Comments on Rape: Gandhi’s Controversies

The India Forum – Life with The Mahatma

Medium – Some Hard Truths About MK Gandhi: Not So Mahatma (Great), After All!

India Today – Mahatma & Manuben: Newly Discovered Diaries of Gandhi’s Personal Attendant Reveal How His Experiments With Celibacy Changed Her Life

The Times of India: Gandhi was obsessed with sex – while preaching celibacy to others: Kusoom Vadgama

Advertisement