20 Epic Showdowns That Nearly Split the USA and Canada (Plus 5 Heartwarming Moments They Actually Loved Each Other)

Chuvic - April 18, 2025

The United States and Canada share the world’s longest undefended border, but their relationship hasn’t always been peaceful. These neighbors have weathered invasions, trade wars, and territorial disputes that nearly broke their friendship. Behind diplomatic niceties lies a history of conflicts that tested both nations. Here’s the untold story of 20 times these countries almost split up and 5 moments they showed genuine affection for each other.

NEXT >>

1. The War of 1812: When Canada Burned Down the White House

America tried invading British North America (future Canada), and it backfired spectacularly. British troops and Canadian militia repelled the invasion, then marched south and set Washington ablaze in 1814. The White House and Capitol went up in flames. Americans still debate whether it was “technically” Canada that burned the presidential mansion. The war ended in stalemate but established boundaries and mutual respect.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

2. The Pig Who Almost Started a War

In 1859, American farmer Lyman Cutlar shot a British company’s pig rooting through his potatoes on disputed San Juan Island. This trivial incident exploded into crisis with British warships and American troops facing off. Both nations maintained military camps on opposite ends of the tiny island for 13 years. No humans died. Only the unfortunate pig perished before Kaiser Wilhelm I settled the matter.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

3. The Aroostook “War”: Fighting Over Trees and Territory

This 1838-1839 “war” featured American and Canadian lumberjacks facing off over valuable timber in disputed territory. Maine sent militia north while Britain dispatched troops. Congress authorized 50,000 men and $10 million for war. Despite this buildup, not a single battle occurred in this bloodless conflict nicknamed the “Pork and Beans War” after militia rations. The Webster-Ashburton Treaty finally settled the border.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

4. Oregon Boundary Crisis: The 54-40 or Fight Showdown

“Fifty-four forty or fight!” became America’s battle cry between 1844 and 1846. The slogan referred to America’s claim to the entire Pacific Northwest up to Russian Alaska. Britain wanted everything north of the Columbia River. President Polk won election partly on this belligerent platform, bringing both nations to the brink of war. They ultimately compromised on the 49th parallel border.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

5. Alaska’s Borders: Gold Rush Tensions

The 1896 Klondike gold discovery transformed the Alaska-Canada boundary into a critical issue overnight. The border suddenly determined who controlled lucrative mining routes. American miners flooded north as Canada claimed coastal ports. Roosevelt threatened to send troops if Canada didn’t back down. The 1903 Alaskan Boundary Tribunal ruled heavily in America’s favor, leaving Canadians bitter for decades.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

6. The Trent Affair: Civil War Diplomacy Gone Wrong

In 1861, the USS San Jacinto intercepted a British mail packet and forcibly removed two Confederate diplomats. Britain erupted with outrage. London dispatched 14,000 troops to Canada and demanded immediate release, threatening war. Lincoln’s government, already fighting the Confederacy, reluctantly complied to avoid a two-front war. This narrow escape demonstrated how Canadian-American relations frequently became entangled in broader imperial politics.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

7. Fenian Raids: Irish Revolutionaries Attack Canada

Fresh from Civil War battlefields, thousands of Irish-American veterans invaded British North America between 1866 and 1871. These “Fenian Brotherhood” fighters had an improbable plan. They wanted to capture Canadian territory to trade for Irish independence from Britain. They conducted several deadly raids, defeating Canadian militia at Ridgeway before U.S. forces intervened. Over two dozen people died in these attacks.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

8. North Atlantic Fishing Fights: Decades of Maritime Hostility

The richest fishing grounds in the world led to bitter confrontations from the 1780s through the early 1900s. American vessels entered Canadian waters, enraging local fishermen. Canadian authorities seized American ships, while American fishermen sometimes violently resisted. Multiple treaties attempted to resolve these increasingly hostile standoffs. The disputes involved every valuable swimming creature. Cod, mackerel, halibut, and lobster all became conflict sources.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

9. The Turbot War: Gunboat Diplomacy in the 1990s

In 1995, Canadian officers seized the Spanish trawler Estai in international waters. The vessel was allegedly overfishing the endangered Greenland turbot. The U.S. sided with Spain against Canada in this unusual conflict. Canadian patrol vessels cut Spanish nets while warships from both sides converged on the Grand Banks. This modern “fish war” highlighted how resource management could still provoke serious international incidents.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

10. Timber Trouble: The Never-Ending Lumber Wars

Since 1982, the U.S. and Canada have engaged in one of the world’s longest trade disputes over softwood lumber. American producers claim Canada unfairly subsidizes its timber industry through forest management practices. The conflict has seen five distinct “Lumber Wars” with billions in tariffs, numerous legal challenges, and multiple attempted settlements. The fundamental disagreements never seem to be resolvable despite temporary agreements.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

11. Auto Industry Battles: Continental Car Manufacturing Chaos

The 1965 Auto Pact created a continental car manufacturing system. However, the arrangement sparked recurring disputes over production quotas, job locations, and market access. The 1980s brought Reagan-era requirements, while NAFTA added new complications. Recent tariffs threatened integrated supply chains. The 2008 financial crisis required government bailouts that strained relations. Auto manufacturing represents hundreds of thousands of jobs, making any dispute instantly political.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

12. Milk Money: The Dairy Standoff

Canada’s dairy system strictly controls milk production, limits imports with high tariffs, and sets prices. American dairy farmers demand access to Canadian markets, claiming unfair trade practices. U.S. politicians regularly condemn Canadian dairy policies. Trump called them a “disgrace” during NAFTA talks. Canadian farmers defend the system as necessary for survival against the massive U.S. industry, which produces more milk than all of Canada.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

13. The Devil’s Lake Dispute: Water Wars Begin

North Dakota’s efforts to drain Devil’s Lake into rivers flowing to Manitoba triggered intense tensions beginning in 2002. Canadian scientists warned about biological contamination, including invasive species. Manitoba strongly opposed the project, demanding environmental safeguards. After years of negotiations, a compromise included a $100 million filtering system. This resolution established important precedents for water management disputes that will multiply as climate patterns shift.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

14. Columbia River Power Struggle: Hydroelectric Billions

The 1961 Columbia River Treaty orchestrated massive dam construction along the 1,200-mile river system. Canada built three dams while the U.S. paid for flood control benefits. British Columbia received half the downstream power generated in the U.S. Renegotiation talks began in 2018. Indigenous concerns, salmon habitat, climate change, and hydropower pricing created complications. Billions in hydroelectric revenue remain at stake.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

15. Keystone Pipeline Chaos: Oil Politics Divide Neighbors

The $8 billion pipeline extension would have carried 830,000 barrels of Canadian oil sands crude daily to U.S. refineries. Environmentalists fought it as a climate disaster while Canadian officials called it critical infrastructure. The project became a political football. Obama delayed it. Trump approved it. Biden canceled it. Billions in investments and thousands of jobs disappeared. Canadian politicians from both parties saw its cancellation as a betrayal.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

16. Steel Tariff Tensions: “National Security” Trade War

In 2018, the Trump administration imposed 25% tariffs on Canadian steel and 10% on aluminum, citing “national security concerns.” Canada, America’s closest military ally, responded with $12.6 billion in retaliatory tariffs. Trudeau called the security justification “insulting” given Canada’s military alliance. The dispute severely damaged relations until the tariffs were lifted in 2019. This conflict revealed how quickly trade disputes poison broader relationships.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

17. Great Lakes Pollution: Saving Freshwater Resources

The Great Lakes contain 20% of Earth’s surface freshwater. They faced catastrophic pollution for decades. Lake Erie was declared “dead” in the 1960s. American coal plants sent acid rain into Canadian forests while Canadian sewage flowed into boundary waters. The 1972 Great Lakes Agreement committed both nations to cleanup. The Cuyahoga River actually caught fire multiple times. Joint research eventually led to comprehensive regulations.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

18. Arctic Passage Tensions: Climate Change Opens New Conflicts

As global warming melts Arctic ice, the Northwest Passage becomes increasingly navigable. Canada claims these waters as internal territory, requiring permission for transit. The U.S. insists they constitute an international strait open to all. Canadian naval patrols face American “freedom of navigation” operations. As shipping seasons lengthen, the disagreement intensifies annually. Military presence, commercial shipping rights, and environmental protection all hang in balance.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

19. Machias Seal Island: The Forgotten Border Dispute

This uninhabited 20-acre granite outcropping sits in the Gulf of Maine’s “gray zone.” It is the last unresolved territorial dispute between the nations. Canada maintains a lighthouse with Coast Guard personnel. American lobstermen fish the surrounding waters claimed by both countries. Confrontations between competing fishing crews occur regularly. During a 2018 escalation, Canadian patrol vessels reportedly stopped and questioned American fishing boats. Neither government seems motivated to resolve the conflict.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

20. NAFTA/USMCA Battles: Rewriting Economic Rules

NAFTA transformed continental commerce after 1994, tripling trade to $1.2 trillion annually. When Trump demanded renegotiation in 2017, Canada faced devastating potential tariffs. The contentious 13-month negotiations featured personal insults, leaked phone calls, and economic threats. Auto content requirements, dispute resolution mechanisms, and dairy market access caused major friction. The eventual USMCA agreement preserved most economic relationships, though with concessions that left many Canadians unhappy.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

21. Friends in Wartime: Blood Shared in Battle

Both world wars cemented a deep military bond between these neighbors. Canada entered WWI in 1914, suffering horrific casualties at battles like Vimy Ridge, where 3,600 Canadians died. When America joined in 1917, the allies pushed toward victory. In WWII, Canada again entered years before the U.S. Both nations’ soldiers fought and died together from Dieppe to Normandy. This shared sacrifice created an unbreakable military partnership.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

22. The Underground Railroad: Freedom Network

Between 1800 and 1865, a remarkable cross-border alliance helped thousands of enslaved people escape to freedom in Canada. This network of routes and safe houses represented extraordinary cooperation between activists on both sides. Americans risked imprisonment under the Fugitive Slave Acts while Canadians created welcoming communities. Cities like Toronto and Windsor became havens. Prominent abolitionists like Harriet Tubman operated across both countries.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

23. 9/11 Response: Operation Yellow Ribbon

When American airspace closed after the September 11 attacks, tiny Gander, Newfoundland, suddenly received 38 diverted flights carrying 6,700 stranded passengers. Residents opened their homes, and schools became shelters. Similar scenes played out across Canada as 224 flights found refuge. Canadians provided food, clothing, shelter, and comfort during America’s darkest hour. The Gander story inspired “Come From Away,” a Broadway musical celebrating this international friendship.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

24. The DEW Line: Cold War Cooperation

During the Cold War, the Distant Early Warning Line stretched 3,000 miles across Arctic Canada. It was a chain of radar stations watching for Soviet bombers. This $300 million joint project combined American technology with Canadian territory. The installations employed both nationalities in Earth’s harshest environments. This massive undertaking demonstrated complete trust during a nuclear standoff with the USSR. The project showed how external threats dissolved bilateral tensions.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

25. NORAD: Watching the Skies Together

Since 1958, the North American Aerospace Defense Command has integrated U.S. and Canadian air defenses into a single system. Based inside Cheyenne Mountain, NORAD includes Canadian officers at the highest command levels. The organization monitored Soviet bombers throughout the Cold War and responded to the September 11 attacks. It famously tracks Santa Claus each Christmas. This remarkable military integration represents unprecedented trust between sovereign nations.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

Conclusion

The U.S. and Canada may fight like family, from shooting pigs to imposing tariffs. Yet their relationship remains among history’s most successful international partnerships. These neighbors have weathered conflicts that might have permanently divided other countries. Their shared geography, values, and economic interests repeatedly pull them back from serious rupture. Their ability to resolve disputes through negotiation rather than warfare offers a powerful model for international relations.

<< Previous