1989’s The Return of the Musketeers was a sequel to The Three Musketeers, depicting events twenty years after the original story. It was a middling movie that opened to mixed reviews, and the reviews remain mixed to this day, with a current Rotten Tomatoes rating in the 60% ballpark. Filming was marred by the tragic death of character actor Roy Kinnear (1934 – 1988), who played the role of Planchet, the servant of the Musketeer d’Artagnan.
On September 19th, 1988, on a film set in Spain, a scene called for the Planchet character to gallop on horseback at speed across a wooden bridge. Kinnear had not expected to perform such a strenuous stunt – he was 54 years old and considerably overweight. Additionally, he had little to no experience in horseback riding, and was described by fellow actors and the filming set’s stunt coordinator as a “nervous” and “incompetent” horseman. That did not stop the film’s director, Richard Lester, from instructing the aging and obese actor to “thunder” at high speed across the Alcantara bridge near Toledo.
As might have been expected, ordering an inexperienced, overweight, and out of shape rider with next to no equestrian skills to charge at top speed across a bridge was a bad idea. Kinnear fell off his horse, and the fall caused him severe pelvic injuries, which led to massive internal bleeding. He was rushed to a hospital, but the doctors were unable to save him, and he died as a result of his injuries the following day.
Kinnear’s family sued the movie’s director, Richard Lester, and a producer, for exposing the actor to unnecessary risks while filming. On the first day of the trial, witnesses testified that although the scene was known to be hazardous, Kinnear was not offered a stunt double. That was then compounded by Lester ordering Kinnear to ride at speed across the bridge, despite knowing that the actor was a poor horseman. The following day, the defendants settled the case for 650,000 British pounds. As to director Lester, he was forced to quit the film making business as a direct result of his role in the accident.
The filming of 1994’s fantasy action movie, The Crow, seemed to have been jinxed. Production had been plagued by safety issues, compounded by money issues that further exacerbated those safety issues. In February of 1993, a construction worker was badly burned on the film set. A month later, an even bigger tragedy struck, to claim the life of one of the film’s stars.
Brandon Lee (1965 – 1993) was an American actor and martial artist, and the son of the legendary actor and martial artist Bruce Lee. Brandon had worked his way up the acting ranks, starring in a number of television films and low budget films during the 1980s, before landing a breakthrough role in the movie The Crow. Unfortunately, his big breakthrough would end in tragedy.
Brandon had started his film career at age 20, starting off as a script reader, and doing uncredited cameo roles. In 1986, he got a role in the ABC television film Kung Fu: the Movie, as David Carradine’s son. He then moved to Hong Kong, where he starred in a number of movies, and in the late 80s and early 90s, he appeared in some B-movies in the US. Finally, in 1992, he landed a starring role in The Crow, a film adaptation of a popular comic series.
Early on the morning of March 31st, 1993, one of The Crow’s pivotal scenes, the killing of Brandon’s character, Eric Draven, by street thugs, was staged in Wilmington, North Caroina. Brandon was supposed to enter through a door, carrying groceries, and be met by actor Michael Massee, who would then shoot him with a revolver loaded with blanks.
However, whoever was in charge of the props and safety that day neglected to properly inspect Massee’s revolver. Had that been done, the inspector would have discovered a fragment of a dummy bullet lodged in the barrel, left there from an earlier firing. An inspection was not done, however, and when Massee fired the revolver, the charge from the blank bullet propelled the fragment out of the barrel. It struck Lee in the abdomen and ripped through his vital organs, before finally coming to a rest against his spine. The injuries proved fatal, and Brandon Lee’s life and budding career were cut tragically short.
This was probably the single most significant on set tragedy, because of its impact on the filming industry and its approach to safety. In the early 1980s, Steven Spielberg and John Landis teamed up to produce a cinematic version of the 1959 – 1964 TV series, The Twilight Zone, for Warner Bros. Studios. The movie, released in June of 1983, received mixed reviews, then and since. It did not turn into the blockbuster Warner Bros. had hoped for, but it grossed enough to count as a financial success. Even before its release, however, the movie had garnered notoriety because of a stunt that caused a helicopter crash, which took the lives of actor Vic Morrow, and two child actors.
The movie consisted of four segments, most memorable of which was “A Quality of Mercy“. It revolved around a racist character, played by Morrow, who finds himself travelling through time to experience the racist persecutions suffered by others. He eventually winds up in Vietnam, where he ends up defending some Vietnamese children against rampaging American soldiers.
To play those children, director John Landis hired a 7 year old ethnically Vietnamese kid, Myca Dinh Le, and a 6 year old Chinese one, Renee Shin-Yi Chen, in violation of California’s child labor laws. The parents were paid under the table, and no permits or waivers were secured to allow the children to work at night, in which the main scene was filmed. As investigators would discover after the tragedy, the filming set was rife with safety violations, and those in charge had taken short cuts to circumvent basic safety precautions.
Most significant were a series of safety violations surrounding the segment’s climactic scene – a nighttime war action sequence, that involved a huge amount of explosives, and a large number of explosions going off. Director Landis did not even attempt to get a waiver – most likely because he knew the request would get denied – to have young children take part in such a dangerous scene.
The scene, shot on the night of July 23rd, 1982, called for US troops in a helicopter to pursue Morrow as he carried two children across a river. It was clearly dangerous, and Morrow’s last words to a friend soon before the tragedy were: “I’ve got to be crazy to do this shot. I should have asked for a double“. During filming, the helicopter hovered about 25 feet above ground, near a debris mortar – a special effects device that uses pressurized air pumped through a tube to propel dirt and detritus, simulating a burst or splatter.
As the helicopter made a 180 degree turn, the debris mortar went off beneath its tail rotor, and blew the rotor clean off. That caused the helicopter to spin out of control, and fall on top of Morrow and the children. Morrow and one of the kids were decapitated by the helicopter’s spinning rotor blades, while the other kid was crushed and drowned. Six other people inside the helicopter were injured.
There had been so many glaring safety violations on set that the accident was investigated as a case of criminal negligence and reckless homicide. As emerged in the subsequent trial, director Landis had been warned of the dangers, but shrugged them off, stating that the loss of the helicopter was an acceptable price for the shot he wanted. When the helicopter pilot had complained that the debris mortar effect was too strong, and that he wanted to get out, Landis yelled at him over the radio to “Get lower! Lower!”
It also emerged that one of the producers had told the children’s parents not to let the firefighters on set, there to ensure compliance with safety regulations, know that their kids would be involved in the scene. The parents were also instructed to hide their children from a welfare worker on set. Additionally, the parents testified that they had never been told that there would be explosives on the set, or that the scene would involve a helicopter hovering over their children.
Criminal and civil litigation lasted for a decade after the accident. Landis and others were charged with manslaughter, but were acquitted after a nine month trial in 1987. Civil litigation continued into the early 1990s. Vic Morrow’s family settled early, but the children’s parents pursued civil lawsuits against various defendants, and ended up collecting millions.
A silver lining of the tragedy was that it shook the filming industry, and shocked it out of its hitherto casual approach to safety on film sets. Studios established committees to set up safety standards, while actors started paying more attention to their own safety, and resisting pressure from directors to do dangerous shots. The Directors Guild also stepped in with its own safety procedures, and began monitoring and penalizing its members for violations of safety rules. It did not completely eliminate dangers on film sets, but it brought about great improvements and made a huge difference.