Winners Write History: The Hidden Crimes of the Allies in WWII

World War II narratives often focus on the atrocities committed by the Axis powers, overshadowing significant violations perpetrated by the Allies. This selective recounting has led to a skewed understanding of the conflict’s moral landscape. The following sections aim to shed light on these underlooked atrocities, challenging the prevailing victors’ narrative and prompting a more comprehensive examination of history.

1. The Bombing of Dresden

In February 1945, Allied forces conducted a series of air raids on Dresden, Germany, resulting in the destruction of the city and the loss of tens of thousands of civilian lives. The raids aimed to disrupt German military logistics and hinder the Soviet advance. However, the extent of civilian casualties and the obliteration of historic architecture have sparked debates over the military necessity versus the wanton destruction of the attacks (britannica.com).

2. Atomic Bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki

In August 1945, the United States dropped atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, resulting in the immediate deaths of over 100,000 people and the destruction of both cities. The bombings led to Japan’s surrender, effectively ending World War II. However, the decision to use such devastating weapons has been the subject of extensive debate, with questions raised about the necessity of the bombings and the availability of alternative strategies to achieve Japan’s surrender (history.com).

3. Soviet Mass Rapes in Germany

During the final months of World War II, as Soviet forces advanced into Germany, they committed widespread sexual violence against German women. Estimates suggest that up to two million women were raped during this period, with approximately 100,000 victims in Berlin alone. These atrocities were largely unpunished and remained underreported for decades. The Soviet High Command was aware of the misconduct but took minimal action to prevent it. (bbc.com)

4. Forced Repatriation of Soviet Citizens (Operation Keelhaul)

Following World War II, British and U.S. forces executed Operation Keelhaul, forcibly returning millions of Soviet citizens—including prisoners of war, civilians, and refugees—to the Soviet Union. Many of these individuals had fled the USSR before the war and had established new lives in the West. Upon repatriation, they faced severe repercussions, including execution or imprisonment in labor camps. This operation has been widely criticized as a betrayal of those seeking refuge from Soviet oppression (en.wikipedia.org).

5. Allied Bombing of Hamburg (Operation Gomorrah)

In July 1943, Allied forces launched Operation Gomorrah, a series of air raids on Hamburg, Germany. The attacks created a devastating firestorm, resulting in the deaths of approximately 40,000 civilians and the destruction of much of the city. This operation highlighted the severe human cost of strategic bombing campaigns, even in the pursuit of victory. The extensive damage to Hamburg serves as a somber reminder of the complexities and moral considerations inherent in wartime strategies (Imperial War Museums).

6. Expulsion of Ethnic Germans (Population Transfers)

After World War II, millions of ethnic Germans were forcibly expelled from Eastern European countries, including Poland, Czechoslovakia, and Hungary. These mass expulsions resulted in the deaths of hundreds of thousands and immense suffering. The United States Holocaust Memorial Museum provides detailed accounts of these events, highlighting the human cost and the complexities of post-war population transfers (encyclopedia.ushmm.org).

7. Treatment of German POWs by the US and UK

During and after World War II, German prisoners of war (POWs) held by the United States and the United Kingdom often faced harsh conditions. In the Rhine meadow camps (Rheinwiesenlager) established by the U.S. Army in 1945, prisoners were subjected to overcrowding, inadequate food, and exposure to the elements. Reports indicate that many prisoners were confined in open fields without shelter, leading to high mortality rates due to malnutrition and disease. For instance, in the Bad Kreuznach camp, approximately 560,000 men were interned in an area that could comfortably hold only 45,000. Denied sufficient food and water, they were forced to eat grass, and the camps soon became a sea of mud (italiausa.com). Similarly, in British-run camps in Belgium, conditions were described as extremely harsh. The Financial Secretary to the War Office, Frederick Bellenger, was reportedly ‘filled with horror’ upon receiving reports on the situation. Consequently, these camps were closed, and all prisoners were transferred to Britain by late July 1946. These conditions highlight the severe treatment faced by German POWs under Western Allied custody during and after the war.

8. Allied Use of Civilian Bombing Tactics

During World War II, both British and American air forces employed strategic bombing campaigns that targeted civilian populations and infrastructure. The Royal Air Force (RAF) adopted a policy of area bombing, aiming to destroy entire urban areas to break civilian morale and disrupt industrial production. This approach led to devastating raids on cities like Hamburg and Dresden, resulting in significant civilian casualties and widespread destruction (bbc.com). In contrast, the United States Army Air Forces (USAAF) initially pursued precision bombing, focusing on specific military and industrial targets to minimize civilian harm. However, as the war progressed, the USAAF also conducted large-scale bombing raids that affected civilian areas, such as the firebombing of Tokyo, which resulted in extensive civilian casualties and destruction. These tactics have been the subject of extensive debate, raising ethical questions about the morality of targeting civilian populations during wartime (medium.com).

9. British Colonial Forces’ Actions in India

During World War II, British colonial forces in India employed repressive measures against independence movements, notably during the 1943 Bengal famine. The British administration’s policies, including the seizure of surplus food and transport, increased rice exports, and a massive cyclone, led to the deaths of an estimated 3 million people (ft.com). Additionally, the British “denial policy” involved confiscating boats and other resources to prevent them from falling into Japanese hands, further exacerbating the crisis

10. Soviet Massacres in Eastern Europe (e.g., Katyn)

In 1940, the Soviet Union executed approximately 22,000 Polish military officers, police officers, and intelligentsia in the Katyn Forest, Kalinin, and Kharkiv prisons. This mass execution, known as the Katyn Massacre, was ordered by Joseph Stalin and carried out by the NKVD. For decades, Soviet authorities denied responsibility, attributing the killings to Nazi Germany. It wasn’t until 1990 that the Soviet government officially acknowledged its role in the massacre (britannica.com).

11. Bombing of Monte Cassino

In February 1944, Allied forces conducted a series of air raids on the historic Monte Cassino Abbey in Italy, aiming to eliminate German defensive positions. The bombing resulted in the destruction of the abbey and the deaths of thousands of soldiers and civilians. The decision to target the abbey, a site of significant cultural and religious importance, remains controversial, raising questions about the ethics of targeting cultural heritage during wartime (historytoday.com).

12. Treatment of Japanese-Americans and Canadians

During World War II, the United States and Canada forcibly relocated and interned citizens of Japanese descent, leading to significant loss of property and livelihoods. In the U.S., Executive Order 9066, signed by President Franklin D. Roosevelt on February 19, 1942, resulted in the internment of approximately 120,000 Japanese Americans, two-thirds of whom were U.S. citizens. They were removed from their homes and placed in internment camps, often in remote areas, where they lived in overcrowded and inadequate conditions. Many were forced to sell their properties at a loss before relocation (archives.gov). Similarly, in Canada, the government detained and dispossessed over 21,000 Japanese Canadians, representing more than 90% of the Japanese Canadian population. Beginning in early 1942, they were forcibly removed from their homes on the West Coast and sent to internment camps in the interior of British Columbia and other parts of Canada. Their homes and businesses were sold by the government to pay for their detention (thecanadianencyclopedia.ca).

13. Allied Bombing of Tokyo

On the night of March 9, 1945, during World War II, the United States Army Air Forces (USAAF) conducted a devastating firebombing raid on Tokyo, Japan. This operation, known as “Operation Meetinghouse,” involved 279 B-29 Superfortress bombers dropping approximately 1,665 tons of incendiary bombs over the city. The resulting firestorm destroyed nearly 16 square miles of Tokyo, leading to the deaths of an estimated 80,000 to 130,000 civilians, making it the deadliest air raid in history. Additionally, over one million people were left homeless. This attack remains one of the most destructive single air raids in human history (history.com).

14. Soviet Deportations of Baltic Peoples

Between 1940 and 1953, Soviet authorities forcibly deported tens of thousands of Lithuanians, Latvians, and Estonians to Siberian labor camps and remote regions. These mass deportations led to significant loss of life and long-lasting trauma across the Baltic states. The Soviet Union’s policies aimed to suppress nationalist sentiments and integrate the Baltic region into the Soviet system. The legacy of these actions continues to affect the Baltic nations today.

15. Allied Attacks on French Towns (Friendly Fire and Bombing)

During World War II, Allied forces conducted extensive bombing campaigns over occupied French cities, aiming to disrupt German military operations and infrastructure. However, these operations often resulted in significant civilian casualties and widespread destruction. For instance, the city of Saint-Lô was 95% destroyed after the 1944 bombardments, earning it the nickname “The Capital of Ruins.” Similarly, the port city of Le Havre was nearly obliterated in September 1944, with approximately 5,000 civilians killed (bbc.com). These attacks have been subjects of historical debate, with some scholars questioning the necessity and proportionality of the bombings, given the high civilian toll.

Conclusion

Recognizing that even the victors of World War II have dark chapters is crucial for a comprehensive understanding of wartime morality and memory. Acknowledging the complexities of history, including the actions of Allied forces, fosters a more nuanced perspective and promotes accountability on all sides. This approach not only honors the experiences of all affected but also contributes to a more honest and inclusive historical narrative.